
At Least Three Strikes
I spent the first half hour or so of this movie feeling a great deal of hostility towards Claire, our main character. This did not bode well for my potential enjoyment of this movie. When I start out feeling that way, my own inner dialogue starts stirring stuff up in my brain, and I start looking at what is going on with a bad attitude. Fortunately, it is hard to dislike Tamera Mowry-Housley for long, and I started to calm down. After all, the character did seem like a genuinely nice person and seemed pretty regretful about her behavior. And then she made me mad again!
So to what am I referring? We meet Claire in New York City being a very successful business consultant. It turns out that she is so good she is actually quite famous, even hanging out with Robert De Niro. She gets a phone call from her lawyer telling her that her beloved uncle (who, it turns out, helped to raise her and is responsible for her happy childhood and “so much of who I am”) has passed away. Their first meeting is shown in flashback at the beginning of the movie when her single mother who is a nurse, takes her to his bar, a community gathering place and institution, while she starts her shift at the hospital. We never find out what happened to her mother. Unless I missed it, we don’t even know if she is still alive or dead. But Gosh, Claire is sure sad about her Uncle. Even though she hasn’t seen or talked to him for 15 years. I actually rewound that part to make sure I didn’t misunderstand. Now I can understand not seeing him, at least if she lived thousands of miles away. (She doesn’t. She lives upstate within an easy commute.) But not even talking to him? With all the talking and texting devices available today? And there was not even an explanation or a reason provided. It’s certainly not the first time a Hallmark lead has returned to their small town having not seen a so-called “beloved” relative for years. But there are always “reasons”. There were no reasons provided here other than Claire’s questionable priorities. It turns out that he has left her his bar, The Tipsy Reindeer, which unfortunately has been floundering in debt because Uncle Lou was terrible with money. That and he liked to yell “Drinks on the house” periodically and to help people in need. Too bad he didn’t know an award-winning rockstar of a business consultant he could contact to help keep his bar afloat so he could continue giving out free drinks and helping people. I’m afraid what we have here is one of Hallmark’s Bad Business plots. There are many many ways The Tipsy Reindeer obviously qualifies, and one is the name. Can there be anything more depressing and lame than a bar called The Tipsy Reindeer in January? Anyway, what made Claire’s neglect even worse was that no one held her accountable. She actually got up at his celebration of life party saying she was sorry she hadn’t been in touch with him “as much.” 15 years without a peep. Yeah, I guess that qualifies as “as much.” And not even a side eye from his loyal patrons and friends. See, now I’m getting all worked up again. And it could have been so easily fixed with a word or two.
The other reason the bar is struggling is that a trendy upscale bar has opened up right next door called Algorithm, and is attracting all the non-locals and tourists and young people who are visiting Garland during the Christmas Season. When Claire sees how empty her bar is the next night, she blames it on Algorithm, and decides to go over there to give the owner “a piece of her mind.” Because having the “audacity” to open a bar next door “that attracts people from all over” is “shameful” and wrong. First of all, this is America. Second of all, I guess Ms. Genius Business Consultant has never heard that A Rising Tide Lifts All Boats, which is why car dealerships are all clustered together as well as restaurants, and, yes, bars. So how many strikes is that against Claire? Well there are more. The first thing she does is try to redecorate to look more like the new bar and not lean into what people love about Uncle Lou’s bar. Luckily, she quickly is set straight by her bartender, Jenna, played by Jennifer Robertson, who was great. Meanwhile, Zach ( Kristoffer Polaha), the manager of the bar and co-founder of Algorithm, has been worming his way into her good graces by demonstrating what a good guy he really is. He has a Grandma! He proposes a friendly competition around a different Christmassy event for each day of the 12 days left till Christmas. Whoever has the most sales by the end wins: If he does, she will seriously consider an offer by Algorithm to buy The Reindeer. If she does, he will find her a buyer for the bar who will respect its legacy. (He is probably thinking of himself here, as he is more of a “Reindeer” type of guy rather that an “Algorithm” type of guy. And he has always wanted to open a “speakeasy” whatever that means in 2026. I looked it up and it actually sounds pretty cool. So for the rest of the movie they fall in love doing Christmassy things like making Candy Canes, Christmas Karaoke, Ugly Sweater contests, Hot cocoa tastings, etc.
All was preceding normally for a Hallmark Christmas movie and it was fine. Tamera Mowry-Housley has never looked lovelier and Polaha smoldered very effectively. I didn’t like either one’s hair, though. Strike 3 took me by surprise. Zach’s friend and the head guy at Algorithm, Jeff, makes Claire an offer for the bar out of the blue. The offer is so generous that she is actually seriously considering it despite all of her fine talk. And I didn’t blame her one bit. She knows it is the right move for herself, the community and even her uncle’s legacy. Jeff talked a lot of sense. But she has to think about it. She and Zach discuss. But then Zach goes behind her back and tries to talk Jeff into withdrawing his offer taking the decision to sell or not sell out of her hands. This was a dick move (sorry) worthy of male attitudes of 1826, not 2026. But once again, no fall out. The movie was all over but the happy resolution, but I was done. The funny thing is that this was written by the same guy who wrote the almost faultlessly scripted The Nights Before Christmas, which aired the day before. I can ignore many wrong things in a Hallmark movie, including fake snow, but the wrong things in this one just kept snowballing.
Youare absolutely right! The movie was just awful and I didn’t even watch the whole thing because I was tired of screaming at the screen telling them how stupid they were. And zero chemistry….
You mean I’m not alone?! I thought I was. No one seems to have been put off by her just cutting all ties for no reason. Thank you.