By Kristina Kamen

Since this is partly a murder mystery and I am reviewing this partly for NetGalley, spoilers are not an option. So this is going to be a short(ish) review. Despite the title, which seems to suggest that this is from the point of view of one main character, this is very much an ensemble piece, with at least 4 of the female characters on the yacht telling their side of the story. The time line jumps from 2 days before the murder, or “the fall”, the day before, the day of, the night of, and the day after ( which is told in third person and is the detective on the case’s perspective), and finally 2 weeks after. It’s all set on a yacht off the Amalfi Coast. Fancy!
As we progress in the story, we read each woman’s perspective: Rebecca, the bride of Preston, “The Husband,” Savannah, the mother, Jacqueline, the ex-fiancé and powerful executive in the Wexley-Thorne family empire, and Tavi, the influencer-girlfriend of Brad, the older brother of the groom, who is constantly filming. We see that everyone has a motive for killing someone or ones. There are no good guys in this story, although some are less bad than others. Some are not inherently bad people but have just gotten off track (in spectacular fashion), Some are very weak people with little to no backbone, some are stupid, some are victims of their emotions they don’t seem to have any control over, and a few are truly despicable human beings. All behave badly and immorally at some point or another. We go from one woman’s perspective to another, each often contradicting each other or talking smack about the other one. One says something like, “So and so’s such a good person,” then we go to another and, “but it’s all an act.” In between we have Detective Moretti interviewing the crew, who drop red herrings left, right, and center, telling completely different stories from each other and from the main 4 characters. It’s up to the reader to separate the truth from the obfuscations, the misunderstandings, the biases, and their ignorance of the whole picture, which informs their sides of the stories.
The pace is great and the chapters are short and punchy. In many ways it was an involving and a fun read. But with one exception, the more I read, the more I disliked most of the characters. A few times, I was given a glimmer of hope, that one of the guests was someone I could really root for, only for the glimmer to be snuffed out. Perhaps someone playing a deep game behind the deep games we are aware of? Maybe not necessarily for the angels but something I could get behind? But no.
Actually, there was one strong character that I was rooting for to triumph over a very despicable adversary. It’s not that they were so great, but their adversary was so odious. Besides the killed and the killer plot, there was a fight for the control of the Wexley-Thorne family empire. This was the part I was most invested in. One makes their plans and we are given to understand that they will be successful in their endeavors to win the game (sorry so vague.) But in the 2 weeks later conclusion where we see the situation from the outside looking in, and it seems nothing has changed. They may still be in the plotting stages, but I don’t know. Given the patterns, they may have chosen to go with the flow and not rock the boat after all. Regardless, if it even happens, we never see the hoped for confrontation and take down on the page. In fact, there is no real justice for anyone, really. As for the wife of the “Husband’s family” there is a weak closure and some hope for the future. But again, given the past behavior, doubt remains.
As for the murder mystery, I didn’t guess who the victim was, nor the killer. But the identity of the victim was a disappointment. Partly because there was a sense that it was an undeserved death, although I never really got a sense of who he/she really was. Same with the killer: a disappointment partly because I never really got a bead on them. The whole thing was kind of basic. A Deep game was being played, but not deep enough, and isolated from the machinations I had become involved in. I hoped to be able to root for the detective, and I did for a while, but was ultimately disappointed in him as well.
Thank you HarperCollins and NetGalley for providing this book for review consideration. All opinions are my own. The planned publication date is March 30, 2027.