
Yoo-Hoo, Marty!
Wow, Wow, Wow. Maybe in a better Hallmark year, I wouldn’t say this was fabulous, but this year it was. Not that this year has been terrible, it’s just been unremarkable so far. This is the first movie that I am giving more than a 7 on my special more generous and forgiving Hallmark scale. This was a 9 or 10. Haven’t decided yet. And I am glad it starred Tyler Hynes, whose roles I have held in disfavor in recent years. And the actor, for, apparently, not lobbying to play characters who broke out of the emo mold he has kind of specialized in lately. Not to say this character was at all happy-go-lucky, or a noble knight in shining armor. But his sadness was earned and not self-inflicted throughout the course of the movie. He had my sympathy this time. He was kind and good. A great performance.
The movie starts out in kind of an unusual way. Marty (Hynes) is in a pool hall regaling his listeners with the tale of the time loop he has been living in for years and years. One of his friends says it sounds like a nightmare, but he says it’s the best thing that has ever happened to him. We flash back to the Christmas Eve when it all began. He is at the traditional Christmas Eve dinner with his family. He is feeling kind of “stuck”, realizing that his life is not living up to his expectations. He manages a small movie theatre rather than making movies himself. He is comparing himself to his cousin, who despite being kind of a schmuck and a bore has somehow made time to do interesting things like travel in Europe and learn to play the acoustic guitar. He walks outside and makes the wish for more time to do things he has always wanted to do. His wish is granted (of course, otherwise we wouldn’t have a movie), and the next day he wakes up to his landlady’s bell-like tones, “Yoo-hoo, Marty!”, and bringing him cookies on Christmas Eve morning just like she did the morning before. I appreciated the fact that the script does not waste time dealing with Marty’s incredulity. He realizes right away what is happening and immediately starts to take advantage of the 15 1/2 extra hours he has been gifted with by living the same day over and over. He reads all the books, sees all the movies, learns many languages (including Slovak, the native language of his motherly landlady), learns to play saxophone among other musical instruments, and becomes a professional-level gingerbread house maker. We have a montage about the various ways he spends his day before we return to the present with his pool hall friends. The next day he sees a girl he has never noticed before, crying and picking up broken Christmas ornaments in a deserted alley. It’s Chloe (Laci J Mailey), who is upset because due to a snowstorm, her parents in Akron will not be able to make it to New York City to spend Christmas with her. They have never been apart at Christmas. Marty tries to help, and she tells him what’s wrong. They start to talk, and their rapport is such that by way of explaining that he has nothing but time to spend, he tells her the truth that he is stuck in a time loop. And she believes him! They have something really special together, and he makes her the focus of every new dawn of Christmas Eve day. Sometimes it doesn’t go so well, he scares and angers her and he ends up in jail. But gradually, he starts to get it right. They go on the perfect date, and she takes him to a private party where they have a great time. He even takes her home to meet his family for the traditional Christmas Eve meal. Their relationship deepens, but only to a certain point. Because of course he has to start over from scratch every day. Early on, when they are discussing his time loop situation, she reminds him that, “Some of the best things in life require the passage of time.” He realizes that maybe the time loop is not the best thing to ever happen to him after all. In order for their relationship to progress and have a real life together, he needs to escape from it. He is still stuck in life, but in a different way. What is the secret key that will release him from what has become a prison? Is it telling Chloe he loves her? Is it something his mother says? Or his father, who spends most of the movie being somewhat of a non-entity? For a while, I thought that maybe Marty might not have been the first in his family to experience this phenomenon (like in Round and Round, another time loop Hallmark). But no matter what, he still wakes up without making it to Christmas Day. He starts to avoid the heartbreak of meeting Chloe and having to start all over with her again. The answer finally comes from one of his pool room friends, who one night, tells Marty a part of his story that he had never told him before, along with some words of wisdom.
The script by Russell Hainline who also wrote Merry Christmas, Ted Cooper! , The Santa Summit and a few other top favorites, was wonderful. True, the over all plot was not original and has many of the elements of a typical time loop story. It’s not a completely new take, but the magic is in the details. Some unusual choices were made. Both in the opening scene, and the closing scene, which did not wrap things up with happy perfect endings all around. But rather, ended with hope and promise. It was self aware, including an inside joke regarding Tyler’s signature toothpick hanging out of his mouth (candy canes for his Christmas movies), both funny and witty lines, a great message (thank-you, not a mention of work/life balance), and moments of real poignancy. It was thoughtful and nuanced. All of the actors were wonderful, with Tyler Hynes’ character development particularly a stand out. It included some cameos from Hallmark regulars, which is always an appreciated feature. Set in the city, the set direction conveyed authenticity. Tyler’s family home being a stand out. It’s not 10 stars because it got a bit repetitive in the middle. LOL. **9 1/2 stars**