by Sonali Dev
HRH’s take on it was this advice to his children: “This is our home. This country is yours. Take everything you need. Give everything you have. From the beginning of time, humans have migrated. We’ve claimed land and let it claim us. Don’t ever fulfill anybody else’s definition of your relationship with your country. How many generations ago their forefathers got here may be how some people stake their claim, but I stake mine with how much I give. How wholly I love. This place called to me, I’m here, it’s mine. And now, it’s yours.”
I’m a soft touch for novels that are re-imaginings of or sequels to Jane Austen‘s works in film or on the page. I have a soft spot for even ones that are not all that good. This is one of the best ones. Sonali Dev did a masterful job of using P and P as an inspiration for similar themes while making it wholly her own. The looseness of the adaptation worked very well. A reader who enjoys contemporary romance or women’s fiction would enjoy this even if they haven’t read Pride and Prejudice. There are many characters in Dev’s novel that are not in the original and many characters and situations Austen’s classic that are not in Dev’s novel. Yet while they diverge in interesting ways, they also mirror each other in the essentials. There is the prideful, arrogant, but socially inept aristocrat (Trisha), the formidable love interest from a suspect background (DJ), victimized loved ones past and present, the evil opportunist, The cold and powerful head determined to “protect” the family from scandal, and the sweet and good sister. But they are deliciously shuffled up. A few scenarios are faithfully and delightfully reset in today’s times. One of the highlights of Austen’s work and this one as well is when Trisha (Darcy) pours out her heart to DJ (Elizabeth) and is rejected.
“I have absolutely no interest in you, Dr. Raje,” meeting the wild pleas in her eyes…it hadn’t struck her for one instant that he might not lap up her proposition or whatever this was.
“This might baffle you, but despite not being a physician, I do have some pride. Although most certainly not enough to withstand the kind of beating you’re capable of dealing it. The kind of beating you’ve repeatedly dealt it from the first time we’ve met. You’re right, I value honesty, so I’ll tell you that I make it a practice not to find women who insult me at every opportunity attractive.”
…she looked entirely devastated. Had no one ever denied her anything?
One thing I really liked about it was how the black hero in the book was portrayed. Too often, lately, it seems like authors are using diverse ethnic characters to make a political statement but they are ethnic in looks alone. In one book I read recently, we’re told that the swoony successful love interest looks like Barack Obama, but other than that, he might as well be a white guy. Maybe I’m being too harsh, but it’s like the author wanted points for having a diverse cast of characters but didn’t want to make her mostly white readership too uncomfortable. Kind of like the Hallmark channel checking the boxes. Oh well, baby steps. In this one, Trisha, although “brown” has always had power and privilege. Unlike DJ who knows very well what is probably going to happen if a white cop sees him breaking into his own luxury car.
“Are you laughing because you think you taught me some sort of lesson?” Because he had, he had pulled the world from beneath her feet…DJ had stood there helpless as a cop reached for his gun for no reason other than fear based in prejudice…Trisha didn’t want him to be standing there in that inequitable ocean, unable to do anything about it. She wanted to live in a world where the waves hit everyone the same way, where everyone could choose how they surfed them. Where the only thing that mattered was ability. And she had allowed herself to become oblivious to the fact that they did not live in that world.
I was not too impressed with the first book I read by Ms Dev. This one also slowed to a crawl in several places. It was repetitive (the constant rhapsodizing about food got old and kind of creepy in places, to me) There were a little too many tangents explored and too much detail which did little to advance the story. But even so, it kept my interest. Sometimes the sentence structure seemed a little off and sentence meaning was a little obscured at first. But this book was a really good novel and a superbly creative riff on Pride and Prejudice. I love books about interesting families and especially ones I have to do a family tree to keep everyone straight. 4 stars for the novel and 5 stars for the Pride and Prejudice connection.
May 16, 2020
11 thoughts on “Pride, Prejudice, and Other Flavors”
I am in AWE of your ability to read so many vastly different books and then do them justice with reviews like this one. I think this article is interesting. (Hush! You started it! ) 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Read and enjoyed the New Yorker article. Thanks!
Oh good. I was really interested in it, yet I wouldn’t even have read it a few months ago and I lapped it up. I’m usually uncomfortable about wasting your time with off topic stuff but I always do feel it’s something worth sharing that you’d enjoy knowing. The only book I’m almost totally unfamiliar with is Mansfield Park and I’ll swear it seems to be the one most frequently cited in so many articles.
I don’t think there’s been a typo in the New Yorker in a hundred years and when I read this: “irruptions of satirical anger”, I thought I had them but then I looked it up 🙂 I don’t think I’ve ever seen that word. I’ve read about all the pain enclosing the common land caused the poor people.
Yes that was quite a reach regarding Knightly’s character. Thought provoking.
I thought that was interesting also. Okay, I got 8 minutes into Ghosts of Christmas Always and I stopped because I can already tell I don’t ever ever want it to end!!! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
You can always watch it again!
No problems there! On my way right now! 🙂 I sent it to so many people along with your review so they’d know what was happening. I was very worried she was going to be kin to him but I wasn’t going to let that get in the way, I’d just pretend it was set in Arkansas. It was amazing and everything else. We are very lucky it was handled by capable people all the way around aren’t we; there wasn’t a cringe or a misstep or anything not done well. There wasn’t a thing wrong. I’m just stunned. Loved the tongue in cheek reference to ghosting. It didn’t fail anywhere. I hope you’ll watch Gifted. I’m not a bit ashamed to recommend it, even after seeing this marvel. I’m going to praise it a little on the proper review too.
Oh loved that you loved it. Amd appreciate
you sharing ny blog. Gifted still in my possession. Anticipate watching it soon.
Cool. Listen for the most satisfying THWACK! in the history of sound. 🙂 Gotta go for Ghosts of Christmas Always now. I missed some of the dialog of the ghosts, I had trouble understanding the little lady. Speaking of her, how you like to have seen her with Leslie Jordan? 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person