The Hypnotist’s Love Story

by Liane Moriarty

The current image has no alternative text. The file name is: hyp

I didn’t have enough other people in my life to cover the loss of this many people at once. I didn’t have any spare aunties or cousins or grandparents. I didn’t have backup. I didn’t have insurance to cover a loss like this.

I’ve read 4 of Liane Moriarty’s novels. This is the 3rd best I’ve read and I really enjoyed it. Such an excellent writer. I will give this one 3.75 stars. In reading the reviews, the two main complaints seem to be that 1) Nothing Happens. And 2) No big twists like in her other novels. 

**Spoiler**

I think the big twist was that there was no twist. She really set the reader up for the possibility that Patrick and Ellen were not to be. She gave Patrick some very unlikable and unadmirable qualities and actions. I felt sure that worse was to come. Ellen was too nice, too reasonable, too in control. Also she was very powerful, with her ability to influence people with her use of hypnosis. I was sure she was headed for a big fall. And at some points, I would have welcomed that. But no. After her very career and livelihood and reputation was threatened by the irate husband of a client, It was quickly resolved by another unlikely and underestimated patient.

A memory resurfaced now of Mary-Kate saying she worked in the “legal profession.” Ellen had just assumed she was a legal secretary. Would she have been more patient and respectful with Mary-Kate if she’d known she was dealing with a barrister? Shamefully, the answer was yes.

We learn that Ellen was not the paragon she was at first painted, and that made her more intriguing and sympathetic. Yes, Ellen learns a few things. As does Patrick.

“I took Saskia’s lucky marble with me when I saw my first ever Scott Surveys client,” said Patrick. “I held it while I waited in reception.” He’d never before referred to a nice memory involving Saskia. It was Ellen’s first glimpse of the other side of their story. “I lost the marble at school,” said Jack. “I looked and looked, and a teacher tried to help me, but we couldn’t find it. I didn’t want to tell Saskia because I knew she’d be sad, and then the next day she was gone. So I thought, Uh-oh, she found out I lost it.” Patrick’s eyes met Ellen’s over the top of Jack’s head. “You thought it was your fault,” said Ellen to Jack.

“I think that’s why I kept putting off taking out the restraining order,” said Patrick. “Because, deep down, I knew I’d treated her badly, even though I didn’t admit it, even to myself.

A potentially devastating meeting with her sperm-donor father ends with a whimper rather than a bang. But that is a good thing!

“Olé!” said Ellen’s father. He lifted his hands above his head and pretended to click imaginary castanets. It was a profoundly dorky dad-like move that would have caused any self-respecting teenage son or daughter to die with shame. “Olé,” said Ellen agreeably. She settled back in her chair to watch the dancing, and as she did she felt one last, lingering doubt about Patrick’s love—a doubt she didn’t know she’d had—quietly drift away. So this was what it was like to have a father.

And our antagonist, Saskia. She finally does hit her rock-bottom by falling down the stairs after Patrick and Ellen wake up in the night to find her staring down at them. She almost takes out Jack, the young son of Patrick, who she mothered for years and still loves. (“Nothing Happens?!”). But no she didn’t set Ellen’s beloved home on fire to kill them all. It was just a sand storm. And Saskia does come out the other side, well on the road to mental health in a particularly touching and unexpected way.
Even Ellen’s briefly met clients each have their own happy endings as well!
So I guess if you’re looking for tragedy, death, destruction, radical reversal of fortunes and personalities, and white-knuckle action, you might be disappointed in The Hypnotist’s Love Story. **end spoiler**

As for me, I was intrigued and drawn in by how all the threads were going to play out. How the characters would learn and grow (or not.) One of the themes of this novel is the importance of having back up. I am reminded of one of the last lines of one of my very favorite movies: About a Boy:

I used to think two wasn’t enough. Now there were loads of people… I don’t know what Will was so upset about. All I meant was I don’t think couples are the future. You need more than that. You need backup. The way I saw it, Will and I both had backup now. It’s like that thing he told me Jon Bon Jovi said: “No man is an island.”

This is her lowest rated novel other than the disappointing Truly Madly Guilty. Since I liked it so much, I am sure looking forward to continuing with the rest of her backlist.

Rating: 4 out of 5.

March 5, 2018

A Rule Against Murder

By Louise Penny

He expected people to play fair. Rules meant order. Without them they’d be killing each other. It began with butting in, with parking in disabled spaces, with smoking in elevators. And it ended in murder.

The current image has no alternative text. The file name is: rule.jpg

The murder of one of the Morrow family provides what is really just a McGuffin in the novel, whose main focus is the absolutely fascinating portrayal of a family as dysfunctional as one can possibly be. And one whose members are not what they appear to be on the surface. Yet the whys and wherefores don’t really hold up 100% under scrutiny.

We find out more about Peter Morrow and are given hope that his disintegration into his dark place may be stopped or at least slowed. I wonder how much Clara understands what lies beneath Peter’s benign surface. She may not be as clueless as she is portrayed. Hopefully we will understand even more by the end of the next installment in the series. We learn more about Armand’s backstory. I hope we will learn more about Reine-Marie in future books.

The murder story itself is a mixed bag. It was very disconnected from the rest of the novel in the end due to who the murderer turned out to be. The “how” is diabolical and clever. The “why” was very weak and the method chosen didn’t make a lick of sense. (Unless I am missing something.)

**3.5 stars, round up to 4 because of the contribution this novel makes to giving insights into the recurring characters as a whole.***I wonder, since this is Peter’s family, if we will be seeing any one them again in future books. That would be interesting.

Rating: 3.5 out of 5.

June 8, 2018

A Fatal Grace

by Louise Penny

‘The names of her gurus,’ said Clara between sobs. Myrna was no longer sure whether she was crying or laughing. ‘Krishnamurti Das, Ravi Shankar Das, Gandhi Das. Ramen Das. Khalil Das. Gibran Das. They even call her CC Das.’ By now Clara was roaring with laughter as were most of the others. Most. But not all. ‘I see nothing wrong with that,’ said Olivier, wiping his eyes. ‘Gabri and I follow the way of Häagen Das. It’s occasionally a rocky road.’

The current image has no alternative text. The file name is: fatal.jpg

Oh my Goodness. I was set to give this book another 4-star rating like the first one, but the final pages really put it over the top. Quelle surprise! We also have some twists and turns and more information in the overarching drama of the Arnot affair and the danger Gamache is in, career-wise. I read a review of this series from someone who binge read this series and now is full of regret for reading them too quickly. I understand the hankering to do that. But I will learn from the mistakes of others and take a small break before going on to the third book. I have to fight really hard not to do what I often do and read all the information I can on a whole series I become really immersed in, almost obsessed with, before I finish it.

Another great thing. I read her acknowledgments, which I often don’t read, and was so delighted that she wrote of her appreciation for Anne Perry, who was kind enough to read her first book before it was published and gave her encouragement. Anne Perry is my favorite mystery writer who I have been reading for almost 40 years and one to whom I am very loyal. I hope I will feel the same way about Louise Penny in 40 years.

Rating: 5 out of 5.

February 26, 2018

Evvie Drake Starts Over

by Linda Holmes

“To some of the people who had watched him grow up, I think he was…a unicorn.” “He didn’t want bigger things?” “No, he did.” “Then why come back?” Evvie shrugged. “Because anywhere else, he’d just be a nice-looking horse.”

The current image has no alternative text. The file name is: evvie.jpg

I listened to this on Audio. Overall I was disappointed in this book. I found the heroine and hero uninteresting, and the heroine borderline unlikable. The journey of their love story and their personal growth lacked drama and tension. Evvie’s problem was that her husband was mean to her despite being beloved by the community and a truly great doctor. The guy, even though he didn’t intentionally hurt her physically, was really horrible. I would even call him a psychopath. The fact that she never revealed her pain to anyone, even her best friend, during her unhappy marriage or after he was killed in a car accident, is the crux of her story. And that she finally had gotten the gumption to leave him the night of his death. She feels bad about this to the point that despite her bad financial situation she has not cashed in her insurance money. I really really did not understand this. She was also abandoned by her mother as a young girl. Really sad and damaging, of course, but it seemed unrelated to her main problems caused by her marriage and how she dealt with it. I really did not get her at all so I was unmoved by the mental anguish that her basically lying to everyone caused.

**spoiler**

I found it unbelievable that her husband did not betray his mental problems while with any of his friends, his workplace, or his parents. I was waiting for his mother, or someone, to come to Evvie in a key scene with understanding and validation. After all, he had a meltdown in high school witnessed by many when a scholarship went to someone else. Had there been a big reveal of some sort where his true nature was somehow made known, I think it would have added a lot to the book. Even her beloved Dad remained in the dark. There was a semi showdown with her mother, but it was over the phone and lame. **end spoiler**

The book was well written with some really nice passages. The premise was good, as was with Dean’s problem and journey, but she didn’t make the most of the opportunities. I hate to give it 2 stars, but in the end, it was “just okay.” 

Rating: 2 out of 5.

November 5, 2019

Dear Mr. Knightley

By Katherine Reay

The current image has no alternative text. The file name is: knightley.jpg

I thought I would really really love this book. I like the two other books I read by the author. I thought they were well written. I love Daddy-Long-Legs and Jane Austen, and epistolary novels in general. But I didn’t love this. I’m not going to rant and rave about it. I will just say that the main reason was that I didn’t like Sam, the heroine. I didn’t understand her, I was bored by her, and she was a real pill throughout the whole book. I was over her at the 4% mark when she was at the end of her rope and out of nowhere she was gifted a full scholarship to Northwestern’s prestigious School of Journalism, and she wanted to ungratefully wheedle out of journalism and into English literature. And the book itself, Sam’s journey to be her real self, whatever that means, was so long, repetitive, and boring. I don’t understand why people cared about her and loved her so, like the Muirs and Alec. Maybe because she looked like Anne Hathaway? And since I didn’t value Sam, I didn’t get the romance that went on and on. And then she turned on him for no reason (not talking about the big reveal here, but her rage when he went to New York.) I did like this wise quote towards the end:

Self-protection keeps you from love, Mr. Knightley—all love. I am so sad at how I’ve kept them at a distance—the Muirs, Alex, Father John, Kyle, Hannah . . . anyone and everyone who has ever stood by me. I played God in our relationships. I determined their value and their worth by how much I let them in, by how much I let them determine my worth. I’m not God.

Rating: 2 out of 5.

July 7, 2020

Beth and Amy

by Virginia Kantra

The current image has no alternative text. The file name is: beth.jpg

Our mother, who never took a day’s vacation in her life, had encouraged all of us girls to work hard and follow our dreams. Meg was the perfect mother to two perfect children. Jo was a bestselling author. Beth was a budding country star. And I . . . I made accessories. It didn’t matter how many Instagram followers or employees I had. In my family’s eyes, I was still little Amy, playing with scraps from Miss Hannah’s quilting bag.

You know that Virginia Kantra’s updating of Little Women to the 21st century is legit when by the end, half of the March family ends up in therapy. She did a thoughtful and effective job crafting a story that reflects the problems and challenges of young women of today just as the original Little Women, did for the girls of that era.

To my surprise, I didn’t enjoy this one quite as much as Meg and Jo. I’ve always thought Amy was the most interesting sister with a good character arc. And Beth, well, Beth. I liked Amy and Trey (Laurie) and their romance, but I’m afraid Beth drove me a little crazy. She was such a wet noodle.

Amy is a successful designer of high-end handbags based in New York City. Her past that fueled her ambition to equal or outdo her sisters, especially Jo, includes her being an innocent victim of a sexting scandal in high school resulting in her being labelled “Easy A.” She also hooked up with Trey (Laurie) in Paris while he was still raw from Jo’s rejection. Giving in to her lifelong crush, he breaks her heart.

Beth was a little tough to take. She is a Grammy award-winning songwriter and rising country music star. But she suffers from stage fright and hates performing. Her powerful boyfriend is a selfish jerk and runs roughshod over her. She keeps saying how in love with him she is, yet she does not enjoy sex with him and fakes her orgasms. She subjugates herself to him and allows herself to be used and taken advantage of while mentally flagellating herself.

We soon find out that she suffers from lifelong eating disorders (she started throwing up on purpose at 10 years old, not to get thin, but to get out of school.) This has somehow morphed into not eating, continuing to purge, obsessively counting calories, and over-exercising to be thin and exert control over her body. But where did all this come from? She had always been loved, supported, and encouraged. There just didn’t seem to be any triggers to cause her disease. In Little Women, Beth was shy, timid, kind, and good. But she was never weak. Far from it. I’m not talking about the eating disorder here, but how she let people treat her. It was wise to choose to have Beth suffer from anorexia rather than scarlet fever, or cancer, for example. I have little doubt that Beth’s thoughts and feelings and the symptoms of her disease are well-researched and authentic. But, for me, the author didn’t really give Beth the foundation or proper backstory the character needed for her problems and behavior to be understood and empathized with. I guess I needed to go on that terrible journey with her. I really needed to understand how she got there, rather than just being presented with the fact. My reaction to Beth bothered me. Because I failed to understand her, her lack of backbone and passivity really started to annoy me early. I grew very impatient and frustrated with her constant tricks and lies in order to appear “normal” in front of her loving family.

It just didn’t seem credible that her family didn’t catch on sooner. She had to be found on the side of the road in convulsions before the “Are you all right?” “I’m fine.” mantra failed to appease them. Or the constant “Have something to eat.” “ I’m not hungry” or “I already ate”, for that matter. Considering everything she was doing to her body and not doing, She would have looked horrible in real life long before she was hospitalized.

I liked how Kantra transplanted some characters from Little Men to round up some love interests for two of the characters. Her weaving of scenes we remember from the original novel with the creative and original modern developments was well done. The exploration of Abby and Ash’s (Mr. And Mrs. March) marriage and personalities was deft. All in all the novel was a message of hope, and working on the relationship with your loved one(s). It was also a message of rising above disappointments and bad things to make a better life than you would have otherwise. In the end, Amy realizes that she wouldn’t have become the person and success she is without them. In Meg and Jo, the characters of Rose, her adopted sister Phoebe, and Charlie Campbell are mentioned. If these characters from Eight Cousins are of the same universe of these two companion novels and are signs of another novel to come, I can’t wait. **3 out of 4 stars**

Rating: 3 out of 5.

June 26, 2021

The Good Sister

By Sally Hepworth

“Can I say something?” he says. “I know you love your sister, but…” He shakes his head, sighs. “Something isn’t right about her.”

**spoilers**Seriously, don’t read this review unless you’ve already read the book, or have no plans to read it.

I don’t understand why all of the descriptions and promotional material for this book tout that there are two unreliable narrators in this psychological thriller about two twin sisters. Rose starts out portrayed as the caring, protective sister. She is telling her side of the story through a journal that her therapist has suggested she write to heal from the childhood abuse that she suffered at the hands of her cruel sadistic mother. Fern is a librarian with sensory processing issues. She finds loud noises, bright lights, and people being too close very uncomfortable. She does not pick up on social cues and takes people’s words literally. She is very awkward and sometimes embarrassing in her interactions with others, much to the readers’ entertainment. she reminded me a lot of Eleanor in Eleanor Oliphant is Completely Fine.

Although there was a niggling doubt (solely because of the “two unreliable narrators” reviews), I was pretty well convinced who the good sister and who the bad sister was was about a fifth of the way through. The first thing that tipped me off was that at one juncture, early on, Rose refers to “you”, a reader of what is supposed to be her private journal. If she’s expecting someone to read the journal, she must have an ulterior motive outside of self-therapy. Around that time, there is a suggestion that Rose might be gaslighting Fern over not feeding Rose’s dog while Rose is in London. Finally, we realize that the target of the mother’s abuse was always Rose, and hardly ever Fern. No person could emerge undamaged from being targeted like Rose supposedly was. Thus, Rose is outed whether she is telling the truth or telling lies. We only have Rose’s and the trusting Fern’s words to know Rose, while we come to see how Fern interacts with and how she is thought of by dozens of objective “outsiders.”

But even without that Fern is just totally lovable and responsible for a lot of humor in the book. The characters in the book respect and even love her or learn to love her despite her eccentric behavior. She also has a love story. The love interest is Rocco, who Fern calls “Wally” because he looked like the “Where’s Waldo” character when she first meets him. He is another one of Fern’s friends and advocates who endears himself to the reader right from the beginning. We learn very early on that he is much more than whom he seems on the surface.

Well before the halfway point all but the most oblivious reader will pretty much have come to some correct conclusions about Rose. The evidence has been building and continues to build. From there it starts to turn from a mystery into a thriller when we realize that Fern is in some kind of grave danger from her sister. There are no twists towards the end of the story, it’s just that the whole truth is revealed a layer at a time. We don’t understand until the concluding pages just how evil and mad Rose has been all of her life.

I really loved this page-turner for the suspense and tension, the humor, the growth that we see Fern achieve, and the sweet love story. I admire the portrayal of the sisters and the gradual reveal of their characters. We learn that part of Rose’s personality is Narcissism. The crowning revelation is the last entry in Rose’s journal which comes as a bombshell as to just how narcissistic and delusional she really is.**5 stars out of 5**

Rating: 5 out of 5.

June 18, 2021

Eleanor Oliphant is Completely Fine

By Gail Honeyman

“But I don’t have any emotional needs,” I said. Neither of us spoke for a while. Eventually, she cleared her throat. “Everyone does, Eleanor. All of us—and especially young children—need to know that we’re loved, valued, accepted and understood . . .” I said nothing. This was news to me. I let it settle. It sounded plausible, but it was a concept I’d need to consider at more length in the privacy of my own home. 

There really is no need to add to the excellent reviews that already exist for Eleanor Oliphant is Completely Fine. The plot has been outlined and sketches of the unusual personality of the eponymous heroine have been many. She is funny, her voice is funny and her relationship with the social situations she gets herself in are downright hilarious at times. Eleanor is invited to a birthday party by her new friends, and remembers that she must bring a gift.

I noticed that I had failed to consume all of my vodka allocation; the best part of a half bottle of Smirnoff was extant. Mindful of my gauche faux pas at Laura’s party, I put it in a Tesco carrier bag to present to Keith tonight. I pondered what else I should take for him. Flowers seemed wrong; they’re a love token, after all. I looked in the fridge, and popped a packet of cheese slices into the bag. All men like cheese….Keith came up to the table and thanked me for coming. I gave him his birthday present, which he seemed to find genuinely surprising. He looked at each item in turn with an expression that I found hard to read, but I quickly eliminated “boredom” and “indifference.”

But the humor comes from a very dark place. You laugh, but you are uneasy doing so. She is not quirky in the same ways Don, the Asperger sufferer in The Rosie Project is quirky. She was a bright and normal child damaged by tragedy and abuse. The thread of a mystery that is slowly revealed throughout the novel of the exact nature and source of Eleanor’s social awkwardness is cleverly done. Clues to the truth are placed by the author for the reader to puzzle out . The author plays fair, and the so-called twist at the end should not come as a major shock. I’ve read that Reese Witherspoon who has proven very perspicacious at spotting and acquiring the film rights to great novels has acquired this one as well. That alone is an encomium enough for this book, for me. The book ends hopefully and positively, and most readers will love her even more by the end of the book than they surely do in the middle. As a side note, Eleanor is brilliant and I learned many many cool words reading this book!**5 out of 5 stars**

Rating: 5 out of 5.

June 28, 2017

P.S. It’s been almost 4 years now. Gail Honeyman has still to publish another book. I hope she is completely fine and not a one hit wonder.

I Owe You One

By Sophie Kinsella

“Family bloody first. I’m not saying Dad was wrong, I’ll never say that, but maybe I’m starting to see “family” differently. It’s not just the people you share genes with; it’s the people you share loyalty and friendship and respect with. It’s the people you love.”

This was a delightfully typical Sophie Kinsella. She is a master at wanting to make me slap some sense into her heroines while simultaneously adoring them. I loved Fixie. Yes, she was very frustrating due to her letting her brother and sister walk all over her, and her blindness and delusion as to her childhood crush’s true nature. The reader is so far ahead of her in seeing what her family and Ryan are doing to her that you just itch for her to finally see the light. It takes quite a while! You think she is going to see clearly and act accordingly, but she just is not strong enough. When both her family and their beloved Farr’s housewares store is in shambles and her horror at disappointing and hurting her mother finally cause her to turn the corner for good, it is all the sweeter and more satisfying. Kinsella doesn’t take the quick route here. When she finally fixes things, it is not by giving her brother and sister the hell they richly deserve. It is out of love and concern for them and her own kind and generous nature, which never wavers. Kinsella gives us a glance at a childhood trauma, that helps us understand her better, and gave me more patience with her than I normally would have had.

The love interest, Seb, is wonderful and has a little more depth than some of her early heroes. He loves and appreciates her but also tells her a few home truths about herself and her family that is one step in her growth and change.

“I think you need to start thinking less about what you owe other people and more about what you owe yourself.”

He is a strong presence and her port in the storm until she makes some mistakes. Luckily, though painful, the separation is not drawn out, and in the long run, it was good that her family and business had her full attention at last. Family first!

The ending is the best ever, with everyone and everything coming together at the end. She could have ended it sooner and I still would have given it 5 stars, but I love that we finally saw the mother back home again, and her family whole and happy and giving Fixie her full credit for everything she fixed. I loved Jake’s reformation. He was so awful for so long, despite Fixie’s efforts, It was hard to believe. The complete turn around at last about gave me whiplash, but I loved it.

The narrator, Fiona Hardingham, was superb. Her intonation and accents made the bad guys, Ryan, Jake, and Uncle Ned even more hateful, and really made Leila, Nicole, and the rest of the secondary characters come alive. Her reading of Nicole made me want to laugh, roll my eyes, and shake her all at once.

If the last two books are any indication, Sophie Kinsella is just getting better and better over the years. Her books are still light and fluffy, with lots of humor, but she has developed some seriousness and depth as well. **5 out of 5 stars**

Rating: 5 out of 5.

April 29, 2019

Surprise Me

by Sophie Kinsella

Where’s the joy in our lives?” He looks around the kitchen with a questing gaze, as though it might be in a jar labeled joy, next to turmeric.

In Surprise Me Sophie Kinsella has achieved an undercurrent of real depth, seriousness, and complexity running under the usual fun and humorous shenanigans. There is potential for real danger and harm in the mostly amusing misadventures of our heroine. Maybe it is because the stakes are higher given that the possible outcome is the breakup of the happy marriage of a mother and father of two little kids. A family is at risk, not just a single girl seeking love and career success. In addition, we are teased with the possibility that our unreliable narrator, Sylvie, is actually unstable and in serious danger of a breakdown once the truth is revealed. Fairly early on in the book, the reader realizes that our heroine has been coddled and cosseted all of her life. She lives life in a bubble wrapped in cotton wool and sprinkled with sparkles. She hero-worships and adores her dead father whom the reader knows early on is not the shining golden hero she thinks he was. We know that she is headed for a fall, and we are in suspense as to what the nature of his weaknesses is and how badly Sylvie will react to her bubble being burst.

Even though we laugh at her antics and inner dialogue and shake our heads at her self-delusions, we like Sylvie. At least I did. She is a sweet funny woman, and good mother, and has her priorities in the right place, despite the fact that she comes from a world of wealth and privilege. Usually the author’s heroes are kind of cardboard and interchangeable, and her heroines kind of shallow. Not so in this book. Both Dan and Sylvie reveal hidden depths. The revealed secrets throw the reader for a loop by both their nature and how widespread the effects. Just when we think we know the extent of the damage, she adds another twist of the knife, and then another. But worry not. The depth of what Sylvie has to confront and heal from makes the resolution all the more affecting. Even powerful. I never thought I would use that word about a Kinsella novel.

Sylvie’s challenges with her personal life would have made this a 5 star book. But Sophie Kinsella ups the ante with a fun career subplot which further reveal her character arc. Add to this mix rich and multifaceted secondary and tertiary characters and you have so much more than her usual light-hearted romp. And the ending was great. It made me want to cheer. I hope SK continues the growth as a writer that she displays in this book: by far my favorite of hers so far.**5 out of 5 stars**

Rating: 5 out of 5.

March 21, 2018